Alternatives to lead-based perovskite materials primarily focus on replacing toxic lead (Pb) with less toxic, more environmentally friendly elements while maintaining desirable optoelectronic properties. The main classes of lead-free perovskites include materials based on tin (Sn), germanium (Ge), antimony (Sb), bismuth (Bi), copper (Cu), and double perovskites that combine various metal cations.
Key Lead-Free Perovskite Alternatives
- Tin (Sn)-Based Perovskites
Sn is the most promising substitute for Pb because it shares similar valence and ionic radius, allowing it to form stable perovskite structures like CsSnI3. However, Sn2+ is prone to oxidation to Sn4+, which reduces stability and device performance. Strategies are being developed to improve Sn-based perovskites’ chemical stability, but currently, their power conversion efficiency (PCE) is still below that of Pb-based materials. - Germanium (Ge)-Based Perovskites
Ge is another divalent cation considered to replace Pb, satisfying coordination and charge balance requirements. Ge-based perovskites tend to have better stability than Sn-based ones but typically show lower photovoltaic performance. - Antimony (Sb) and Bismuth (Bi)-Based Perovskites
Both Sb and Bi, belonging to group 15 elements, have been used in lead-free perovskites and double perovskite structures. They produce more stable compounds with less toxicity but often exhibit lower efficiency than Pb-based counterparts. These materials are promising for optoelectronic applications beyond photovoltaics, such as photoluminescence. - Copper (Cu)-Based Perovskites
Cu has been explored as a Pb substitute to achieve novel lead-free perovskites. While these materials show improved stability, their photovoltaic performances are generally modest compared to Pb or Sn halide perovskites. - Double Perovskites and Other Complex Structures
Combinations of metals like Bi, Sb with monovalent cations form double perovskites that are lead-free and exhibit promising optoelectronic properties. These structures offer a pathway to more environmentally benign perovskites but still face challenges in matching the efficiency of Pb-based materials.
Summary Table of Alternatives
| Alternative Material | Advantages | Challenges | Applications |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tin (Sn) | Closest match to Pb in structure | Oxidation of Sn2+ reduces stability | Solar cells, LEDs, photodetectors |
| Germanium (Ge) | Good charge balance, stable | Lower efficiency than Pb and Sn | Solar cells, optoelectronics |
| Antimony (Sb) | Stable, low toxicity | Lower photovoltaic performance | Photoluminescence, optoelectronics |
| Bismuth (Bi) | Stable, environmentally friendly | Moderate performance | Photoluminescence, photocatalysis |
| Copper (Cu) | Improved stability | Moderate photovoltaic performance | Novel optoelectronic devices |
| Double Perovskites | Lead-free, tunable properties | Efficiency and stability optimization | Versatile optoelectronic applications |
Overall, tin-based perovskites are currently the front runners among lead-free options, despite challenges with stability, while Ge, Sb, Bi, Cu, and double perovskites offer alternatives with trade-offs in efficiency and stability. Research continues to focus on improving these materials for practical applications in solar cells and other optoelectronic devices.
Original article by NenPower, If reposted, please credit the source: https://nenpower.com/blog/what-are-the-alternatives-to-lead-based-perovskite-materials/
