Comparing the costs of chemical and thermal treatments for PV recycling involves understanding the complexities and trade-offs between these methods. Here’s a summary of the key points:
Cost Comparison Overview
- Chemical Treatment: Chemical methods are often more advanced, allowing for higher recovery rates of valuable materials like silicon and silver. However, they typically consume more chemicals and time, operating at a higher cost level compared to simpler methods. For example, innovative chemical processes like base-activated persulfate solutions can achieve high recovery rates but might increase costs due to the complex chemistry involved.
- Thermal Treatment: Thermal methods involve heating to break down components and can also achieve high material recovery rates. While they might be more energy-intensive and costly than mechanical methods, they can be less expensive than advanced chemical treatments. The cost-effectiveness of thermal treatment can vary based on the specific technology and application.
Specific Costs
- Chemical Processes for Solar Grade Silicon: The total costs for advanced recycling processes, including chemical methods, can range widely. For example, costs for solar grade silicon production can vary significantly, with CAPEX and OPEX contributing to overall costs. Reported total costs per panel can be between €14 and €23 for advanced chemical and mechanical treatments focused on high-purity silicon.
- General PV Recycling Costs: The general cost range for recycling a solar panel is between $10 and $40 per unit, depending on factors like panel type and recycling technology. The choice between chemical and thermal methods will influence these costs, but specific figures for each method are not universally reported.
Conclusion
While chemical treatments often offer higher material recovery rates and purity, they typically come at a higher cost due to the complex chemistry involved. Thermal treatments may be more cost-effective in certain cases but require significant energy inputs. The choice between these methods depends on the specific goals of the recycling operation and the availability of resources to manage costs effectively.
Original article by NenPower, If reposted, please credit the source: https://nenpower.com/blog/how-does-the-cost-of-chemical-treatment-compare-to-thermal-treatment-for-pv-recycling/
